Xtreme

this looks way to open and not extreme

 

Few things, this map is quite messy, some objects are placed crooked, overlap (some are interlocked but still overlap). There is no Geo - Merging, and I now that isn't why a map is good but MLG maps are that much better with Geo-Merging.

 

i like it but it is a bit sloppy, perfect some forging techniques and try and make it really nice for a second version

 

looks good maby i will dl l8ter like others say just clean it up a bit and add more cover but nice first post and welcome to FH

 

looks like onslaught without interlocking and less cover 6/10

 

You did interlock, but just very sloppily. You should use corner walls and boxes as support beams to straighten things when interlocking. Also, most of this map looks extremely like MLG Onslaught, which isn't the best because Onslaught is better built than this, so people won't want to download the... well, sloppier version. It's extremely hard to top official MLG maps. But I'd still give this a 3.5 out of 5 because it's your first post and you ACTUALLY DID IT CORRECTLY. Thank you so much.

 

its ok
could use a little cleaning up to make it a little cleaner but other than that is pretty good

 

1. Yes, it is a bit messy. Some of the merges cross over a bit, but this is great for a first post.

2. There is a perfect geo-merge in the first picture.


I saw that this thread had a 2/5 star rating before I entered it. That disappoints me. This guy embedded pictures and gave a description on his first post. How many first posts do that? I've seen ForgeHub's members give better ratings to people who lazilly embed only one picture and simply give links to the rest because "that's all they have to put."

To the map-maker: If you come back and check this thread, don't let any rating get you down. There are places in here that could use some work, but I think 2/5 is a bit harsh.

 

i would say that if you're planning on adding to this, then it's a good start
but it is pretty sloppy and open in spots
keep working at it.

 

this map looks a little open and az little messy, maybe post a v2 where the interlocking is smoother and you put in more cover.

 

how is it extreme?

 

This map has a very good idea...the only thing that i see that is wrong is that you didn't interlock...and i bet that is why most people are dissing your map...just interlock and it will become an even better map...good layout feels like onslaught...if you don't know how to interlock go on Halowiki and look at forge because i added how to interlock into items and into the geometry of the map...im not advertising just trying to help out...all n' all good map

 

Meh it looks a little sloppy (my own opinion). Please take a few more hours' time on this and post a V2.

 

it could have been done better mabey a v2
(i thought it looked alot like onslaught then i realized it was based off of it

 

ya its a bit messy and needs more cover. 6/10

 

its kinda of slopy and open 2/5

 

There's a box in the ground... there is interlocking, but it's just messy interlocking. I'd say straighten everything and Reject is right, need help go to Halowiki. BTW even in a video game mathmatics are important. V.2 should be a 5/5

 

looks good, uv got some good ideas but some places look abit open or rushed a version 2 would b good but this still looks fun