I might pick up #2, I like the idea. It's probably not something I'll do in the near future, but I might try making it. I can already imagine the jail, and there's a couple other things I'll throw in as well.
I might pick up that small pillar thingy, although I had somthing like that in mind for a map already, this just inspired me more.
Cool, I'm glad it helped you. Can't wait to see any of these maps actually being made, they would get a definite download from me.
This should be in the imagination database. There was no reason to make a new thread, the reasons you gave are irrelevant, and it is completely possible to get constructive criticism in that thread as well.
Whats the aim to idea three? It sounds like theres no point to it. If you explained it more so I could get a clearer idea of It I might make it. BTW anyone who takes up idea 3 is welcome to use my map to help them start.
I made a map very similar to the columns idea, it was in the sky bubble with loads of floating smaller objects around a centre block, it was called asteroidz, unfortunately with hammers and swords etc the gameplay didnt really work :\. the hammers would send people flying and with swords youd end up lunging off the edge. Im sure that someone could change it around a little bit and make one that plays well
Made some changes to the thread: -Changed color to red (Other color was nasty and boring) -Added an idea -Clarified some stuff I see tons of people saying that they might or that if someone did it, it would be cool. I made this so people could actually attempt these. If anyone actually wants to try to make one, I'd love to know.
Agreed, plus a lot of these have already been done or are similar to what you put down. All the ones I have seen are: 1,3,4,5,10,11,12 An additional bunch wouldn't work out well such as 8 and 13(unless banshees have a shitload of health, I've already tried that. Maybe Anti-Air...) But I could imagine making a ship on longshore for asset. Plus you just bumped the thread DON'T NECROBUMP. YOU SHOULD KNOW THAT (BIG, ANGRY LETTERS!).