Signature of the Week 17 Discussion

CaMOfo, please don't come into the G&A and seek out a way to impress the staff. Especially when you don't have a clue what your talking about. You're the one who seems ignorant to me.

 

This is for talking about entries, and everything else that deals with sotw. stfu, gtfo

which is better?



or

 

LOCK, two is much better. One just looks horrible with the bottom like that. But, if you make it a rectangle like most signatures, and get rid of some of the blur. Then, I'd say number one. Also, could you comment on this one? I'd like to get your views on it.

 

The sig is too bland.
First off, way too much head space, and the colors are meh. I like the clipping mask, kinda, i think you used to much. The wolverine like slashes are a little too distracting, and don't really go with the sig. I do like it though, i can live with the slashes.

Better?




The image i used is a blurry image, when i sharpen it it looks like ****.

 

Maybe you could try dodging to lessen the blur? Anyways, yeah I know it's very boring. But, I wanted to keep it kinda simple. I will surely try to fix it up a bit.

 

How about this? I changed the background.

 

how is this. oh and it should be smaller but it doesnt want to be the size i tell it to be

 

Simple, yet attractive. I like it very much, except the disco ball isn't all that great. I like it being there, just not the way it's in.

How about mine?

 

Wow, I accidentally asked for CnC in the submission thread. Lol, I totally thought I was in this one. Anyways, I forgot to ask what everyone's take is on my signature. Your thoughts?

 

how is it now i moved the disco ball out a bit

 

Juggernaut, I think it's amazing. The colors, and effects are perfect. Text is great too. The only thing I would suggest would be to smudge the vector like colors on her face. Just smudge the edges of each shade a little. Then, it will not look so pixely.

Megathumbs, I like the simplicity, but there are two things I don't like. The disco ball and the edge-things look too complex compared to the style.

 

or


I dun like em very much

 

I liked it where it was. I don't really like the black rim though.

Now, will someone rate mine?

 

It would yes, but that would go against the SOTW theme wouldn't it =) But thanks for the CnC.

 

Are we ignoring my sig? I would like someone's opinion please.

 

Heres mine im still new to this but whatever.

 

Well you have the right idea, but the images don't match.




Which one do you like?

 

seriously, has anyone seen a more awesome sig? lol thats my entry

 

I like the second one better.

 

Umm, it's... great. I think it could use more effects though.

I thought so, is there a problem with the second one though?