PETROLEUM This map is a large set of pipelines. It plays well with CTF, Territories and Slayer. This is a great map for this reason: There is a trench in the middle for shotgunners. If you stay on the outskirts where you spawn, you snipe. And BRs are useful if you are defending at close range while on the pipeline itself. Every weapon placed on the map has a great use. Please DL and give feedback: Bungie.net : Halo 3 File Details
The map looks good, except the needler should be taken out, as it makes gameplay unfair. There should be more than one shotgun, but if you must have one, move it somewhere else, like on the side of the map. You'll learn why if you play it with other people. Finally, there should be vehicles. I would put a mongoose on the right of the beginning of each base. Other vehicles won't work for this map. Although there wasn't much originality, an update of this map would make it much better. Until then though, the map gets a 6/10.
One thing is that he could have tested it and it could of just played together nicely, But i don't know for sure. You have a great sense in creativity but your map is just not cutting the standed that it could be. The map itself is fine but if you want people to download and have fun on this map it does really need more. You need to create more of a landscape for players to interact with. Example walkways, side bases, ect. The reasonwhy is because your map looks pretty empty and nothing interesting. I am hoping for a version 2 of this map. If you want to add vehicles on this map you will possibly need to change your map around a bit to accommodate vehicles. And next you post a map please write up a Small Description Of The Map this includes what gampetypes is this map best suited to.It helps people understand what to expect on your map. If you want to get your map tested its a good idea to go to the testers guild they can recomend more then i ever could cause they test it. So all you really need to do is just add stuff and make it clean its as simple as that, if you want i maybe able to help if you want it.
I say add a few base-like structures where the needler spawn is. Add cover to the pipeline. And maybe a neutral base above the camo.