You judged a map solely upon the pictures given; saying "it looks as if" without giving any basis for your claim is a general no no. Plus you gave an out of 5 ranking. Stop doing that.
I lol'd. You offered little feedback directly related to the map(point being, you could easily throw that comment into any map) and you gave absolutely no justification. What part is sloppy? How do you fix it up? Why are there too many weapons? I highly doubt you've even loaded up the map(or at least didn't go on it before commenting). It's spam. No doubt about it. Whoever made the map plays no part at all to the moderator.
The thing is you need in depth post, has more detail, like if you downloaded the map, I am sure you could of found more about it. Good and bad. Saying that is too short, and not that helpful in sorts. I mean you could of told him, what kinds of weapons, or how to clean it up, you know. EDIT: People posted before me while typing...lol