Red Dead Redemption Halo: Reach Scott Pilgrim Vs The World: The Game that's really all ive played, and i loved all 3. RDR because it made my eyes gloss over like 3 times from the story and absolutely stunning score, the visuals to complement it didnt hurt either, i still think about that story... Reach because it brought everything we've grown to love about halo one notch higher, and knocked it out of the park with that campaign. I'm still playing it nightly. Scott Pilgrim because im a scott pilgrim fanboy to the point of disease, the epic Anamanaguchi soundtrack actually affected my music tastes a bit, dat 8-bit. it also brought my non-gaming family and friends into gaming which hasn't happened since Lego Star Wars.
I played a lot of games this year, but Mass Effect 2 was crap, and Bioshock 2 failed to live up to how great Bioshock 1 was, Fallout New Vegas was good, but I personally preferred Fallout 3. And Call of Duty is possibly one of the worst ****ing games I've ever played. You know, in my life. So my nominations go to Halo Reach and Golden Sun: Dark Dawn (which I haven't played yet).
Red Dead Redemption Minecraft Reach RDR was such a fun game, and although its gotten quite a bit of news... I'm sure it would be getting a lot more if it were made by a different developer. Reach is good, but its better than most other games out right now. Minecraft... what else is there to say