There is a pretty good remake of Coagulation on the forums. I'm sure you've seen it if you're a fan of the map. It's probably the closet we'll get but there is a huge flaw, I think. If you go to the top of the base you can easily spawn kill people. It's not even funny how much it can be manipulated. It's either like you said that the bases get to high or the geography isn't suited to accommodate those type of bases.
i joined in halo:3, so i'd have to say: 1.Lost platoon from Odst as firefight 2.Vallhalla 3.Sandtrap and this was really close with sandtrap so: 4.Last Resort
Valhalla, Sand Trap, and I know we have bloodgulch but the older bloodgulch had a better feel to it... I would rather have an improved graphics version of that.
-sidewinder -beaver creek -rat race And wouldnt it be nice to make a BETTER remake of Bloodgulch Bungie?
-headlong -containment -waterworks i'd like to see hang 'em high, lockout, and some other smaller maps in matchmaking as well, but these can be remade pretty accurately in forge. a lot of the larger maps are very difficult, if not impossible to recreate in forge, so they would definitely have to be properly remade
-Longest __________________________________ -Headlong (a lot of potential for invasion) _______________________ Containment
I'm surprised more people haven't said Last Resort. I know it's already a remake in itself, but I love that map and would gladly pay for it again. That and Valhalla are probably the two maps I'd like to see return most. My favourite H3 maps were smaller ones like Pit, Guardian and Narrows for CTF at least, but I don't feel that any of those would work particularly well in Reach as remakes. I think larger scale maps would be great with the new playstyle though, especially Valhalla. They'd have to forego the Banshees though, imo at least. Oh, also agree that Prisoner would be fantastic. Jeenyus' version is great but pretty laggy on splitscreen, having a full remake would be really nice.
You can defiantly tell which game people in this thread joined the halo franchise in this thread. My picks: 1, Boarding Action (With armor abilities it would be awesome to play on) 2, Terminal (I miss playing king of the hill on the tracks) 3, Backwash (imagine how kick ass scary infection games would be with the low visability)
psh, I played them all, I just love a lot of later Halo 2 maps and definitely miss a good portion of Halo 3 maps.
I say bring back, Containment, the outside could make for a very good winter forgeworld. Boarding action, because it would play great with armor abilities, without a doubt. Construct, because it is all around a great map and I personally think it would play the best in reach that any other maps. But my favorite maps are, The pit, Lockout (original), and Guardian. Other honorable mentions are Midship, Sanctuary, Prisoner, Chill out (original) and turf, construst and maybe narrows. ^-^