It's actually not a bad signature... Just crop off the left side up to the edge of his gun. And get rid of the text.
Personally, I'd say numbuh 2. I like the guy's positioning on 2 and 3, but I also like the extra text around the "Dead Space" bit. So, two IMO.
That border isn't too great. Ugh. And crop it more, IMO. If you don't mind... That's not a bad tag right there.