Well, this sig needs quite a bit of work. - The text doesn't match the sig, and it is plain. V1 was better. - It looks like you used a messed up render because the guy's arm is very thin in the middle, as though whoever rendered the guy cut off the top half of the guy's arm. If it was a stock, then you covered the top of his arm. -The lighting needs somework, because its looks like you just brushed the top with a soft white brush and in this instance it just looks weird and unnatural, especially against the background. -The render/focal needs to be blended more; right now, it looks like he was pasted onto the background. Overall, this looks unfinished. It could turn out to be a nice sig, though.