The Docks: Looks like you did a good job pulling off the theme of the map, but I can't comment on gameplay. Mostoma: Looks like an "improv" map....
Yeah, I think it's a good move to feature maps from all categories, so you can appeal to all audiences.
First Repression, now Quadrant. Complex lives on! I'm not sure where you drew you inspiration from, but it definitely has similarities to Complex...
Full of fail? Maybe I was missing something, but it sounded like he was trying to help. No, I wouldn't mind. I plan to do one last update to it....
Why are you being an ass? If your friend's camera work is jittery, it is very possible that could have more viewers with better camera handling....
If you had to choose one or the other, then gameplay is the obvious priority. A map is meant to be played, not stared at. But you don't have to...
No, you are very wrong. I could go into your map thread, and start pointing out every single thing that I see as a flaw with a negative tone. If...
In game. I saw Lilia, Jinx, and acouple others. Ill check again today.
Can you hold it for a day? I'll be on later.
Appreciate the feedback on Angst. It was an idea I had from the beginning not to use color, so I would have to force myself to make each room...
Angst: Bungie.net : Halo Reach : File Details Feedback: Gameplay
Regardless of if the name of the map is important to you or not, it is a very important part of the presentation. The fact that you didn't name...
Your maps will have a life if they are good enough. If they fall into the abyss, there's probably a reason. You need to stop adressing people...
First of all, Congrats Nutduster. I'm not a mini game guy, but this is the type of mini game that is hard not to enjoy. @Saltine: Everybody has...
Not really. You need to think about balance and player flow on this map. No matter how many rocks you have in the grass, it serves no purpose to...
I'm going to be brutally honest, because I feel that it is better than ignoring the opportunity to help someone. You are clearly a new forger,...
Strife by a Chunk: http://www.forgehub.com/forum/reach-competitive-maps/139406-strife.html Ventricle by WARHOLIC:...
It's disappointing that you forge only to get your maps into matchmaking, rather than forging because you love the art of map design. Salot is the...
I remember when Prince asked me if he could do a review of Angst, and I was like "sure, that'd be great". Then he said that I would be the one...
Chunk, it appears your asymmetric-map-building balls have really started to drop. I checked out all of your recent maps, and they are all huge...