This is my first map in Halo 3 i am releasing. Ok, today me, daCOOKIEkiller and kanadian halo make this: File Set with Map, Video and Screenshots http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DHn4QHrbs1k Please Post you comments.
Its not bad.....but the one they have up on the Sandbox Community Choice thing right now for Bungie is a bit better. Slightly bigger, cleaner, and more accurate to the Halo:CE version.
Sorry, but this just isn't good. It doesn't even stack up as a non-remake. Everything is boxy and square, whereas everything in Beaver Creek was curved or polygonal to provide interesting angles of attack. The river actually made me snicker a bit, sorry... You could go back and fix the map, or start over. Also, try watching Forging 101 for some extremely helpful tips for creating your own forge masterpiece. 2/5
Okay. Whom Cares about cleaness and how god the remake is. He Worked Very Hard On this map. And Besides its almost an exact remake of Beaver Creek In Halo 2. I Love how he made the water. Many Map Makers Dont add that. 4/5. I am downloading This. How Dare Any One Say This Is Garbage. Nice Job Rougie.
The layout and ratio of this map to Beaver creek is almost perfect, although as Jsten said, beaver creek isnt actually that squarish, and it has more cover, 3.5/5
You know what the issue with your "river" is? The river in HCE and H2 didn't reflect grenades back up or away...the shield doors do. Which seriously messes with gameplay.
Ok stop defending your friend it is only constructive critisism jeez and besides ot dose need work when people play remakes they want it to feel the same and besides i can tell from the pics that is rushed because it is boxy and there is almost no merging signs that it was rushed. No offense but their needs to be more time spent on this forging make a v2 and i would take a second look but until then
It doesn't matter if you know him or not, he doesn't need anyone defending his map. I understand you're trying to be nice but your post is just spamming up the thread. and SPAM!!!! Any way onto the map. It does look boxy, and instead of using blocks as the ground, use walls, it's much easier to stack blocks, and make them neater. If you fix up the map and make it less boxy and make the bases bigger. And the map is too small for a teleporter. 2/5