Alright, we decided to have a Halo mongoose signature battle. We each had two stocks and we made two signatures each. Also, in order to stop anyone from being biased, I will be hosting bot sets of signatures so no one will be able to know who's set of signatures is who's. Now without further ado, here are the stocks and signatures. Stock 1. SIG1 SIG2 Stock 2 SIG3 SIG4 Now, you get to vote once for each stock image. Person with most votes wins. Me and Z will tally the votes. This will go on for 3 days so please vote! Also, make sure you give a reason. Think of this as a mini SOTW. Lastly, do not be biased. If you know who's signature it is do not be biased, vote for what looks best. Commence the voting!
The fact that they are unlabeled makes no difference. The styles are very clear. I vote for: For great stock positioning, fantastic blending and text and the fact that the placement of the lights somehow makes the mongoose look like a pimp-mobile. Great blending and artificial motion as well as a good focal and a cool rough feeling. Great text once again.
Hahaha, thing is that you didn't give a reason. So your next vote and this doesn't count. iWin. DO NOT BE BIASED. PLZ THANX.
hmm...I'm interested to see whose whose... Stock 1: Top one, I like the coloring and flow and general style better... Stock 2: Bottom one, the same reason as the first...There are two definite styles here, I'm going to say whose I think they are though...
Better? Since I'm nice, I'll count your vote if you give an extremely good reason. Go give your good reason.
I vote for SIG 1 and SIG 4. SIG 1: I love the text and the signature has great colors. Good job on the focal and the sharpening. Smudging is great and so is the depth. SIG 4: Seems a little over sharpened but still well done compared to the other signature. The other sig is too blurry and uses some very bad colors.
Nevermind Hari, it would seem that even in huge-ass bolded font, its to hard to read. @Sic, you must add a valid reason or the votes will be disqualified.
Sig 2,3. Sig one is too crowded. Sig four is too crowded. Neither present a nice focal point, and both drag away from it.
Can we get some more votes please? If you look you can take at least one minute and vote for two of the signatures.
For the first stock I am going to go with sig number one. I really do not like the colors and the border of the second. The first one is not magnificent because I think it is a little oversharpened but I definitely say its a little better. For the Second Stock I am going with sig number 2. Once again I do not like the color tent of the other one. And personally I think sig number 2 is way over sharpened but has better flow and lighting. I can definitely tell that Sig 1 and 4 were made by the same person.
Sig 1 and 4. The other signatures are mostly monotone, and 1 and 4 overall have better quality effects.
Sig 2 and Sig 4 Sig 2: I love the greens, everyone knows i love green.. well not really.. also, the c4d use makes it look very professional. The depth and lighting are great too.. (sorry bud) Sig 4: well, for one, i just didnt really like the other one, but also, i liked the sharpness of it, and it really looks like it is moving. also, the text- "BOOST" really shows in the rest of the signature. there is motion everywhere and it looks great