Oh my GOD im confused...

I say the Stars Wars one. It has many vibrant colors they flow perfectly and the pop out perfect is perfectly placed. But as you know, I'm a major GFX noob.

And just being curios, what the GFX site with pros, for I'm searching for sites dedicated to just GFX. Thanks.

 

I don't why, but the Star Wars one is just not cutting it for me. The Gears of War one feels as if it's popping out at you. The bullet or whatever on the Star Wars one seems to be to long and I think therefore I'm voting for the current.

 

id say the long one. Idunno i just have a preference for longer sigs. And its definitely better than the gears one IMO. The gears one is different, but just not as good.

 

Let's see, which is the dumbest looking one... er... I mean.

The first one. The very first one.

 

I like the Star Wars one. However, I wonder what it would look like if it were more popped out.

 

Short one looks better. And are you saying none of us are pro? The center part of the render is oversharpened and looks LQ. TOPAZ IT! Also, like i mentioned on LD, it needs focal work. Overlay a gradient or something to increase focal.

 

its really nice,
but the big yellow streak looks dodgy and the commandos faces are over topaz'd
also i dont really like the half battle droid on the left

 

over sharpened then

 

I would go with the longer Star Wars one. The smaller one just feels too small, and the GoW one just isn't very good in my opinion. It's ok, but nothing special.

Also, on a side note, that Star Wars game was the ****!

EDIT: Republic Commando! That's it! Couldn't think of it for a while and it bugged me.

 

start wars one it looks alot neator

 

Try voting.

Actually, I think there should be a rule that the people entered can't vote.

 

I had to choose yours. Your pop-out was the only one that made sense. I bet if you could vote on yours, you would.

 

Yea, that's coming from a guy who's advertising his sig work in his sig.