Hes trying to say that fat Kid maps with big Armorys that make the zombie quit 75% of the time is bad. I mean, wheres the fairness? Or super weak zombies and a giant open place from where they spawn to the Humans, and the humans having Battle Rifles. Those are really bad too. People always say the Bungie Gametypes are dumb, but just think, would you rather have the 3 year old's games, or Bungie infection.
I believe a very intelligent and depressed man once said; "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder." Truth, we can't compare what some people would think "sucks" and another would think "awesome." What we can do is choose not to play them. Why do you care about the Bungie favs so much? If they suck, oh well. They're not going to ruin the fun of the game itself.
Based on popularity or ratings, the maps that "rise to the top" on b.net will be full of novelties and gimmics. It works for screenshots because you only need to glance at a screenshot to see its awesome. A map needs to be played and tested though, important factors like spawns, weapons or balance need to be considered as well as how cool it looks. Though it may be wishful thinking, it would be great if bungie could take advantage of the work forge hub puts into finding the best maps being produced. As it stands at the moment, the community files section on b.net is the last place I would look for a good forged map.