I like the first one the most, but I like the incorporation of the forge symbol and halo thingy in the bottom banner. Maybe make the bottom shinny/glittery, like the top one.
Im going to start a suggestion in customer service for these. And to go with that, a petition in off-topic.
woot, i got to see these before anyone else, haha i like the first one version 2 the best, it is really great, keep up the good work