What type of Poster are you?

This thread is dedicated to all the members of Forgehub and all the different type of posts and comments left behind. I decided to make a thread on the matter and find out what type of poster you are.

There is a big reason why this is in General Chat and not in Off Topics, I don’t want spam, or silly responses. This is my first serious poll and it does have to be treated as such.

I also would prefer if you don’t lie, there is no proof that you make these posts (Although they can check your posts) but there is also no proof that you will continue to make these posts. Be truthful I’m sure the moderators won’t infract you (unless they catch you actually posting these posts)

So now... there are options. What type of poster are you?

Post Name: Quick Replier
Description: A poster who gives out a one sentence review. These posters are common within the lower ranks and tend to slimmer down as the ranks go up and are normally called the post boosters.
Rank: Very High
Example: This is a good map I have to check it out, could use interlocking here and there. 4/5

Post name: Positive negative reply.
Description: A poster who says the map or a certain part is good, and complains right after the compliment. Tends to be a short reply and generally from the population with low rep.
Rank: High
Example: This map is really good, the interlocking is priceless. Could use some work though, because interlocking is good, but a bit sloppy.

Post name: Kiss-up Post
Description: A poster who only compliments on the map whether it’s good or not. This can be found within the lower ranks and tends to be short regardless.
Rank: High
Example: Wow, this map is good, great interlocking. The people who say is bad have no clue what they are talking about. 5/5 Great map I’m downloading.

Post name: Spam Post
Description: Obvious signs of spam can be found in this post. These posts tend to have an infraction sign at the lower right corner, very short with very little helpful advice or comments.
Rank: Average
Example: Great post, the map is good. Downloaded 5/5.

Post name: Complainer Post
Description: A post varying in size, it tends to be short regardless and lists all the negatives about the map without suggestions. Tends to be slightly rare, and varies on the member’s skill.
Rank: Low
Example: This map needs interlocking, it looks dull. I am not downloading because it is too common so yea… 2/5

Post name: 2-4 Paragraph post
Description: Generally the most helpful of posts, listing all visual and sometimes game play problem followed by suggestions. These posts are not common and tend to be written and posted by high ranking members.
Rank: Low
Example: Well, not to shabby, but there are flaws. But don't worry I will give you a 2-4 paragraph review. So where to start, I guess I'll start with the problems. First of all is the sloppy and irregular interlocking, I see some parts interlocked over there and some parts interlocked over here, and then I see no interlocking. It's a mess to tell what is interlocked, and then when I do see something interlocked it does not look perfect, I'm not saying it has to be 100% perfect, but not angled off by 5 degrees.

Your next problem is the weapons, where exactly are the weapons I see very few scattered around on the pictures, it does not look like there are that many weapons. I did notice the Battle Rifle on the other hand, and I ask you why. The map does not look like it requires battle rifles. The range is close which equals assault rifles.

Now those are the bad parts, now for some good news. I have to say that the thread is superb, it's a good one-two minute read. and each picture has a small description. You added recommendations for game types and that is pretty pro.

While the map may lack proper interlocking it does look competitive, show me more pictures of weapons, from what I saw a simple weapon change would make this competitive.

Overall I give it a 3/5 for a good thread, and a not to shabby map. I lower two points for the lack of interlocking and bad weapon placement.

Post Name: Small Review
Description: Under normal circumstances these tend to help the thread owner, these are somewhat difficult to find but tend to give a decent review.
Rank: Medium
Example: The overall design of the map is flawed, you need to adjust your weapon placement. I would recommend moving the battle rifle and replacing the Shotgun. Interlocking could use some help as well. Get these factors right and you got a good map.

Post Name: 10/10 Post
Description: These posts are helpful and very organized, the thread owner can see the problems with his map at a simple glance, these posts are rare and often tend to be helpful pointing out both Cons and Pros
Rank: Low
Example: Originality: 7/10
Puzzles have been done over and over again. This does at least have a few original ideas. The free-skip grav lift idea was a very nice original touch.

Aesthetics: 8/10
Doesn't have anything too pretty, but of course it is a mini-game map, so at least it serves its purpose.

Playability: 9/10
Puzzles are always fun to play for me, especially with original puzzles. So as long as this doesn't have glitches, it should be good.

Design: 8/10
Puzzle maps always have to be well thought out to be sucessful. Good job on this. I've made one before... it was pretty sucessful, but I know how well you have to think it's design.

Construction: 9/10
As long as the construction went as well as the design it should be just fine.

Overall Rating: 8/10

Post Name: Honest Post
Description: A truthful post that goes straight to the point, these are common and tend to be located in newb threads. They are not offensive and offer little advice.
Rank: Medium
Example: The map needs interlocking; the game play looks like it sucks. I would have to give your map a 2/5 interlocking is really bad. Try going to Forging 101 to get help.

Rules: Failure to follow the following rules will be considered spam and you will be reported.

• Do not; I repeat do not post a 1 sentence response to this. Explain why you are this type of poster.

E.G = I am (Insert type of poster here) because…

• Do not post pictures, or quote anyone.

If you do not find the type of poster you are, then make sure it is not one of the following and post it without fear. If it is a unique post not posted then I will add it on to the list.
This is not a free post thread. I will not accept short posts; your post must be on topic.

Disclaimer: These posts where created by RadiantRain, and all info on this thread is based on opinion.

If this post does not belong here please move it to off topics.

 

Thanks, but please recommend something if you do not find it, it will help me expand on the list.