Map Name: Refuge Created by: HCTF Reaper Original Map: Halo 3 Citadel Download link: Fileshare Search>by gamertag>HCTF Reaper>Refuge
This looks great! Looking forward to checking it out, especially since I can remember how good your Citadel remake for Reach was.
I must admit I felt a little scared when you posted your remake of this map after mine. Especially considering your Reach remake won the last contest. Interestingly enough, we have both used a very different forge style. I think both maps have their pros and cons. Also, it may appear I'm trying to talk up my map here. This was not my intention. I merely am curious to see people's opinions on both of our maps. What people prefer in either map.
You posted this while I was editing my post. I can see where your coming from but I never said that I disrespect his map. I am just curious to hear people's opinion of either map.
I understand you want feedback and you want people to pay attention to your map. I want the same just as much as anyone. However, you have a thread dedicated to your map. That's where it belongs, and that's where you get your feedback. This is his thread, dedicated to his map that he worked on. This is where he gets his feedback. It's disrespectful to him to try and draw that attention away towards yours, or in the very least, piggy back off of him. Kd, this looks extremely solid and well built. After you won the last competition, I'm excited to run around on this and give it a shot. Good luck.
UberAURORA, I think I understand where you're coming from. At some point I intend to try both yours and kdavis' and give you both some feedback. As you were saying, I think it's really cool how you both have used different forge environments when making the same map. As a fellow member of this forging community, I see nothing wrong with you referencing your map on kdavis' thread or vice versa, because you both seem to be good sports about it and are actually doing the community some good by letting people know that they can download and compare both versions. Most people advertise their maps on their signatures anyway... And besides, if you were really out to steal people's attention, you would be shooting yourself in the foot by posting here, since every time you comment on someone else's map, the other person's map ends up on the first page of the forums where it will likely receive the most attention anyway. I don't think that's your motive, though. I for one will probably download both and enjoy playing on both pretty soon (so long as the frame-rate is good for both, of course). [br][/br]Edited by merge: Got to do a walkthrough of this yesterday, and of the remakes out there for Citadel, I have to say that I think this one plays best. It looks great AND it doesn't seem to suffer from frame rate issues (at least not in single player mode). I highly recommend this one.
Thanks guys for checking out my map. I did not have as much time as I needed to add dominion and Extraction gametype. Also there are a few small fixes I need to make before it is actually complete. This is basically a preview and I will have all three finalized versions of my maps in my fileshare within a week. FYI I will label the final versions v1.0 in the map description. thanks again and remember to keep an eye out for the updated versions. GT:HCTF Reaper P. S.- No hard feelings uberaurora I know you didn't mean any disrespect. And I appreciate you looking out for me thesilenceisbroken.
I just made mine Extraction compatible. Also, I don't think its necessary to make it Dominion compatible since its a smaller map. Dominion works way better on larger maps. Extraction however is very good on it and it was mainly put in on account of it being my favourite new gametype.
I am currently adding both dominion and extraction to all of my three remakes and am confident that they will all play very well.