Remake Guardian

]by far the most coolest looking remake of guardian i have seen, but it should have way more spawns, did you check the original one for referance? and it would be nice if it was set it up for oddball or ctf because they were pretty fun for it. oh yeah...WELCOME 2 FORGEHUB!

 

Wow, this map is great!

This map is truly a very good remake, yeah sure there are a few things that could use tweaking (Spawns and some minor things) but when it comes down to it it's an excellent remake. Probably one of the best I've seen. I like its unique look compared to that of other remakes, and that you used Forgeworld's layout to your advantage. Instead of just building the remake in the water like other people when they cant figure out how to use the landscape/don't want to deal with it. Definitely Downloaded and playing games on it.

 

I suggest you actually bother to download the map before you comment on it. Everything you have said is 100% untrue and is just going to fill the creator with false hope and make the creator think that they have nailed the map on the head when the completely missed said nail.

Now then. I downloaded the map and got a quick run around on it. I have to say I was far from impressed. The map lacks almost all the right measurements for a Guardian remake, has a low quality of forging and overall felt like a re-imagining of the map we all know for Halo 3. I suggest looking at Guardian on Halo 3 before attempting this map again.

I suggest learning to use co-ordinates or learning to use the zoom in feature to move objects more slowly and move them into a position where they cause less of a bump. This site has many forge tutorials and Youtube should hold a few video representations for you.

The only upside to this was that I couldn't find any framerate lag on the map.

I suggest you learn your way around forge before attempting such a massively hard task. Good luck on your future maps and good luck on remaking it in the future if you choose to do so.

 

Wow, your an asshole. You think you could do better?

Stop bitching and go ****ing build this remake and then come back and talk your ****.

 

@darkricochet
dude hes not being an asshole, hes giving the author some some constructive criticism. He didnt insult at all, he was just giving advice. This site isnt all about the compliments, hes giving useful tips to help the creator. Hes not "talking ****", and he isnt bitching.

As for the map, it looks pretty decent. some sizes look a bit off, and some things look a bit unusual. But im glad to hear the maps fr is great, and i also like how you used real grass instead of tin cups.

 

Unlike you I have given constructive criticism and done it nicely.
I suggest you take an attitude check or grow up before posting again.

I'm downloading your newer version now, but won't be able to check it out until my brother gets his ass of Black Ops.

 

That ramp leading down to sniper is incredibly steep. There appears to be lots of inefficient piece usage as well. Also, the center of the map appears to be made out of the round bunkers found on Hemorrhage, meaning the gravity hammer room will be nothing like it's supposed to be. I have to agree with Rawr here and say this really needs some work to be considered a remake.