Since the first community playlist has come out, I've been keeping a list of all of the maps I have played on and a rating of each. This list is designed to both express my opinion of the maps now in matchmaking as well as to help predict which maps will stay and which will go as they progress. I will continue to post my ratings after I have played most of the ones from each update, so this should compile a pretty good list of which maps have made it in as well. Fell free to comment, disagree on my ratings, or just chime in about certain maps, all comments will be read and appreciated. Ratings: 1- I cried 2- not very impressive 3- average, would play it again 4- sweet design, would download 5- sheer brilliance, must have it! Update 1: Jan. 4, 2011 Name Playlist Rating Reverence - Team slayer - 3/5 Thrust - Team Slayer - 2.5/5 Endzeit - Team Slayer - 3.5/5 Capacitor - Team Slayer - 4/5 Obsidian - Team Slayer - 3.5/5 Aspiration - Team Slayer - 3/5 Ziggurat - Team Slayer - 3/5 Elevation - Team Slayer - 3/5 Fave of the week: Capacitor- The most balanced of the first batch I could find and also the funest to play on. It had good aesthetics and a good use of colors so I always knew where I was. Till Next update!
Couldn't you have posted your opinions in this thread? This thread really is just serving the same purpose as that one is. Also, Obsidian definitely doesn't deserve a 3.5/5