I was thinking of doing Death Island. I'm not sure if I will yet but I have some stuff planned out. I think most of the map is doable, just not the cliff tops but thats not such a huge loss seeing as most of the time people just tele-camp up there.
I know this is a bit off topic, but it would be cool to have an contest about remakes of other games maps.
Oh wow, if someone can make a good remake of Yoyorast Island somehow that would be fantastic. I'm not sure if it will be possible in Reach but if it is, I'll be looking forward to it.