well like your poll says waterworks would have been amazing as a remake but i do dont think coag would fit the H3 criteria seeing as we have valhala as it is... but heritic/midship? your right not the greatest ever... especialy seeing as zealot is right around the corner i know people say its not a remake but use your heads people its deffinitly deprived from midship... --- i see it all over the place mainly xbox and on the "marketplace" tab on Halo 3 it self. it says something like.... "do you have the final 3 halo maps? buy here only 800 mspts" ya know... something along those lines.....
Heretic is by far one of my favorite H3 maps. Then again, I love covenant maps in general. Although it's true, I really would've preferred something like Ivory Tower or Waterworks. One thing that I really miss from the old halos were the gigantic, moving structures. The only significant one I can think of in H3 is the Last Resort wheel, and even that isn't as cool as some of the H2 stuff. I do have a strong feeling, though, that even if Reach isn't shipped with many remakes, I'm sure there will be at least one remake per map pack. Well, I'm not positive, but I've got a strong feeling.
Heretic was an alright map on halo 2 but they really killed the map in halo 3 it just didn't feel like the same map to me. Heretic the design of the map was crap though you would almost get spawnd killed every match on both halo 2 and halo 3.