It was a very fun map, the puzzles were good, good variety, really liked the puzzles in the last room to get the Whale at the end. That being said there is room for improvement, I played this with 3-4 other people to which they thought it was good and there opinion was the same, the conclusion after the picking up the whale lacked in whether you knew if you were done or not and the killing you if you got something wrong and having to reset the game was annoying.

This is a hard map for me to review. On one hand, I think some of the puzzles are great! Particularly the first puzzle and the pipe puzzle. However, I thought a few of the puzzles were a little cheap/ambiguous like the "similar rooms" puzzle and the puzzle where hitting a switch spawns another one somewhere else random hidden in the same room.

I think the aesthetics are very good, while slightly sloppy in some sections (overlapping textures, objects going through roofs, etc.). Additionally, I didn't like that you were forced to restart the map when failing certain puzzles. I know you said this was unavoidable, but I think you could have figured out a way!

I really liked the concept of the whole second part of the map in the city! I loved exploring the city and figuring out what each room was for. Overall I mostly liked the map with just a few complaints. Great job! :)