There's just something about killing things with futuristic weapons in castles.

 

Had a quick look through and would like to suggest a few adjustments.

1. I would remove the teleporters. Having put so much effort into the layout and aesthetics, the teleporters will be used way too often. The players won't feel like taking the long stairs to get to the higher grounds.

2. MORE FLAGS! This one large flag at the side of a castle really adds to the atmosphere so maybe consider adding a few more around the map?

3. The top mid section of the map is a little open and bland. A few crates here and there to add a bit of cover maybe? Also the lighting could be improved in that area. Whilst there are torches on the wall, add some invisible lights to bring the interior to life.

4. This is a rather small nitpick but for the grenade launcher position, could it be moved to where the cylinder is? It may just be my OCD kicking in, but there's something off with where it's placed. It's just a nitpick haha.

- Overall, this is one of the best [If not] THE best castle maps I've seen so far. It definitely gives the Eichenwalde vibe from Overwatch.

Pop me a message if you decide to add some of these suggestions and I'll play test a few times.

 

1) No
2) Um.
3) NO
4) nah
Aesthetics aside,
This map holds up as much as it could from the original in 2009

 

I don't think UnknownEmerald's comments required critiquing.

 

Glad you read thought it! If any changes are done to this map give me a shout as I'd love to feature it. Whilst I know it's a remake, don't be afraid to try new things. Like you said Halo 5 mechanics are different so it might bring something new to the map! Whilst it's already beautiful, it can still become better

 

Correct, but the changes suggested are without warrant. If you haven't played the map, don't suggest changes that alter gameplay. The teleports are crucial in circulation, and adding crates is never a good idea. It's lazy cover, which diminishes gameplay, and provides "ring-around-the-rosey" encounters. Overall, it's just a silly suggestion, especially without understanding how the map plays. Or the original for that matter.

Any artistic suggestions are fine, but there is no reason to judge the design based on a quick look through, or for that matter, even a few play tests.
Always remember, if you are critiquing a map, you need to understand it.

 

You have played the map one, get off your high horse and learn about design...

 

Yeah no you're wrong.

And you're an idiot.

 

No need to be Given to fly's butt buddy!

 

Not only this but if you're going to add cover on a castle map at least suggest something midevil themed like some balistas you can take cover behind or perhaps a battle torn area with some makeshift cover, instead of.....Crates? In most cases you want to redesign rather than add cover, and like others have said it defeats the purpose of a remake, at that point its a re-imagination.

 

Hey I just posted your map on Rorak Kuroda's Facebook page. I'm interested to see his reaction, you did such a remarkable job recreating his map. Anyone would be honored to see people remaking their work even though they left the Forge community. I miss Rorak now...

 

We need more H3 forge remakes. Honestly some amazing 4v4 designs hidden in there.

 

Love the back to back core features!! More please!

Seen this map around, looks neat. I'll have to check it out

 

Except I can distinctly remember Given, Multi, Vyctoriouz, and Kuroda along with myself playing this map plenty of times throughout the life of Halo 3 because it was regarded one of the best custom designs in the games, and was frequently used during custom game sessions. There's a difference between a "high horse" and wisdom.