Debate God

Discussion in 'Off Topic' started by Nitrous, Dec 17, 2008.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. aMoeba

    aMoeba Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,369
    Likes Received:
    0
    Stop. Saying. Religion. Pick a damn religion to debate over.

    I am not going to even bother debating over all these
    Bábism
    Main article: Bábism
    Azali
    [edit]Bahá'í Faith
    Main article: Bahá'í Faith
    [edit]Christianity
    Main article: Christianity
    See also: List of Christian denominations
    [edit]Catholicism
    Main article: Catholicism
    Western
    Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association
    Independent Catholic Churches
    Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church
    Heenum Catholic Church
    Philippine Independent Church (In communion with the Anglican Church and the Union of Utrecht)
    Polish National Catholic Church
    Union of Utrecht (In communion with the Anglican Church)
    Old Catholicism
    Liberal Catholic Church
    Roman Catholicism (Latin Rite)
    Sui iuris (Including Byzantine Rite churches)
    Traditionalist Catholicism
    Eastern
    Eastern Catholicism (Eastern Churches in Communion with Rome)
    Eastern Orthodoxy
    Eastern Orthodox Church
    Bulgarian Orthodox Church
    Georgian Orthodox Church
    Greek Orthodox Church
    Romanian Orthodox Church
    Russian Orthodox Church
    Serbian Orthodox Church
    Ukrainian Orthodox Church

    Oriental Orthodoxy
    Armenian Apostolic Church
    Coptic Orthodox Church
    Ethiopian Orthodox Church
    Syriac Christianity
    Assyrian Church of the East
    Indian Orthodox Church
    Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church (In full communion with the Oriental Orthodox Church)
    Syriac Orthodox Church (In full communion with the Oriental Orthodox Church)
    Mar Thoma Church (In full communion with the Anglican Church in India)
    Syriac Catholic Church (In full communion with Rome)
    [edit]Protestantism
    Main article: Protestantism
    Anglicanism (via media between the Roman Catholic Church and Protestantism)
    Anglican Communion
    Church of England
    Church of Ireland
    Church of Wales
    Episcopal Church (United States)
    Scottish Episcopal Church
    Pre-Lutheran Protestants
    Hussites
    Lollards
    Waldensians
    Anabaptists
    Amish
    Brethren in Christ
    Church of the Brethren
    Hutterites
    Mennonites
    Old German Baptist Brethren
    Baptists
    Brethren
    Catholic Apostolic Church
    Charismatic movement
    Christadelphians
    Christian Israelite Church
    Unification Church
    Christian Science
    Dispensationalism
    Elitism
    Esoteric Christianity
    Evangelicalism
    Free Presbyterian Church of Ulster
    Lutheranism
    Methodism
    Messianic Judaism
    Most Holy Church of God in Christ Jesus
    New Thought
    Pentecostalism
    Oneness Pentecostalism
    Pietism
    Holiness movement
    Quakerism
    Reformed churches
    Puritans
    Presbyterianism
    Congregational church
    Religious Society of Friends
    Spiritism
    Espiritismo
    Swedenborgianism
    Christian Spiritualism
    United and uniting churches
    Unitarianism
    Universalism
    [edit]Restorationism
    Main article: Restorationism
    Adventism
    Millerites
    Sabbatarianism
    Seventh-day Adventists
    Christadelphians
    Latter Day Saint movement (Mormonism)
    Church of Christ (Temple Lot)
    Community of Christ
    Rigdonites
    The Church of Jesus Christ (Bickertonite)
    The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (a.k.a. LDS)
    Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints (a.k.a. FLDS)
    The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints (Strangite)
    Iglesia ni Cristo
    Jehovah's Witnesses
    Restoration Movement
    [edit]Gnosticism
    Main article: List of Gnostic sects
    Christian Gnosticism
    Ebionites
    Cerdonians
    Marcionism (not entirely Gnostic)
    Colorbasians
    Simonians
    Early Gnosticism
    Borborites
    Cainites
    Carpocratians
    Ophites
    Hermeticism
    Medieval Gnosticism
    Cathars
    Bogomils
    Paulicianism
    Tondrakians
    Persian Gnosticism
    Mandaeanism
    Manichaeism
    Bagnolians
    Syrian-Egyptic Gnosticism
    Main article: Syrian-Egyptic Gnosticism
    Sethians
    Basilidians
    Thomasines
    Valentinians
    Bardesanites
    [edit]Islam
    See also: Islam and Divisions of Islam
    Kalam Schools
    Main article: Kalam
    Ash'ari
    Kalam
    Maturidi
    Murji'ah
    Mu'tazili
    Kharijite
    Main article: Kharijite
    Ibadi (Only surviving sect)
    Azraqi
    Harūriyya
    Sufri
    Shi'a Islam
    Main article: Shi'a Islam
    Ismailis
    Mustaali / Bohra
    Jafari
    Twelvers
    Alawites
    Alevi / Bektashi
    Zaiddiyah
    Sufism
    Main article: Sufism
    Bektashi
    Chishti
    Mevlevi
    Naqshbandi
    Tariqah
    Quadiriyyah
    Suhrawardiyya
    Tijani
    Universal Sufism
    Dances of Universal Peace
    Sunni Islam
    Main article: Sunni Islam
    Hanafi
    Berailvi
    Deobandi
    Hanbali
    Maliki
    Shafi'i
    Groups sometimes considered non-Islamic
    These religious traditions are not recognized as parts of Islam by mainstream Islamic fiqh, but consider themselves to be Muslim.
    Ahl-e Haqq (Yarsan)
    Ahmadiyya
    Druze
    Nation of Islam
    Moorish Science Temple of America
    United Submitters International
    Zikri
    [edit]Judaism
    See also: Judaism and Jewish Denominations
    Rabbinic Judaism
    Main article: Rabbinic Judaism
    Orthodox Judaism
    Haredi Judaism
    Hasidic Judaism
    Modern Orthodox Judaism
    Conservative Judaism
    Masorti
    Conservadox Judaism
    Union for Traditional Judaism
    Reform Judaism
    Progressive Judaism
    Liberal Judaism
    Karaite Judaism
    Main article: Karaite Judaism
    Modern Non-Rabbinic Judaism
    Alternative Judaism
    Humanistic Judaism (not always identified as a religion)
    Jewish Renewal
    Reconstructionist Judaism
    Historical groups
    Essenes
    Pharisees (ancestor of Rabbinic Judaism)
    Sadducees (possible ancestor of Karaite Judaism)
    Zealots
    Sicarii
    Sects that believed Jesus was a prophet
    Ebionites
    Elkasites
    Nazarenes
    Sabbateans
    Frankists
    [edit]Rastafari movement
    Main article: Rastafari movement
    [edit]Mandaeans and Sabians
    Main articles: Mandaeism and Sabians
    Mandaeism
    Sabians
    Sabians of Harran
    Mandaean Nasaraean Sabeans
    [edit]Samaritanism
    Main article: Samaritanism
    [edit]Unitarian Universalism
    Main article: Unitarian Universalism
    [edit]Indian religions

    Main article: Indian religions
    Religions that originated in Greater India and religions and traditions related to, and descended from, them.
    [edit]Ayyavazhi
    Main article: Ayyavazhi
    [edit]Buddhism
    Main article: Schools of Buddhism
    Nikaya schools (which have historically been called Hinayana in the West)
    Theravada
    Sri Lankan Amarapura Nikaya
    Sri Lankan Siam Nikaya
    Sri Lankan Ramañña Nikaya
    Bangladeshi Sangharaj Nikaya
    Bangladeshi Mahasthabir Nikaya
    Burmese Thudhamma Nikaya
    Vipassana tradition of Mahasi Sayadaw and disciples
    Burmese Shwekyin Nikaya
    Burmese Dvaya Nikaya
    Thai Maha Nikaya
    Dhammakaya Movement
    Thai Thammayut Nikaya
    Thai Forest Tradition
    Tradition of Ajahn Chah
    Mahayana
    Humanistic Buddhism
    Madhyamaka
    Prāsangika
    Svatantrika
    Sanlun (Three Treatise school)
    Sanron
    Maha-Madhyamaka (Jonangpa)
    Nichiren
    Nichiren Shū
    Nichiren Shōshū
    Nipponzan Myōhōji
    Soka Gakkai
    Pure Land
    Jodo Shu
    Jodo Shinshu
    Tathagatagarbha
    Daśabhūmikā (absorbed into Huayan)
    Huayan (Avataṃsaka)
    Hwaeom
    Kegon
    Tiantai
    Tendai
    Cheontae
    Yogācāra
    Cittamatra in Tibet
    Wei-Shi (Consciousness-only school) or Faxiang (Dharma-character school)
    Beopsang
    Hossō
    Chan / Zen / Seon / Thien
    Caodong
    Sōtō
    Keizan line
    Jakuen line
    Giin line
    Linji
    Rinzai
    Ōbaku
    Fuke Zen
    Won Buddhism: Korean Reformed Buddhism
    Kwan Um School of Zen
    Sanbo Kyodan
    Vajrayana
    Shingon Buddhism
    Tibetan Buddhism
    Bön
    Gelukpa
    Kagyupa
    Dagpo Kagyu
    Karma Kagyu
    Barom Kagyu
    Tsalpa Kagyu
    Phagdru Kagyu
    Drikung Kagyu
    Drukpa Kagyu
    Shangpa Kagyu
    Nyingmapa
    Sakyapa
    Jonangpa
    New Buddhist movements
    Aum Shinrikyo (now known as Aleph)
    Diamond Way
    Friends of the Western Buddhist Order
    New Kadampa Tradition
    Share International
    True Buddha School
    Vipassana movement
    [edit]Hinduism
    See also: Hindu denominations and Contemporary Hindu movements
    Agama Hindu Dharma
    Hindu revivalism
    Lingayatism
    Hindu reform movements
    Arya Samaj
    Brahmo Samaj
    Shaivism
    Shaktism
    Tantrism
    Smartism
    Vaishnavism
    Gaudiya Vaishnavism
    ISKCON (Hare Krishna)
    Major schools and movements of Hindu philosophy
    Main article: Hindu philosophy
    Nyaya
    Purva mimamsa
    Samkhya
    Vaisheshika
    Vedanta (Uttara Mimamsa)
    Advaita Vedanta
    Integral Yoga
    Vishishtadvaita
    Dvaita Vedanta
    Yoga
    Ashtanga Yoga
    Bhakti Yoga
    Hatha yoga
    Siddha Yoga
    Tantric Yoga
    [edit]Jainism
    Main article: Jainism
    Digambara
    Shvetambara
    [edit]Sikhism
    Main article: Sikhism
    Khalsa
    Nihang
    Namdhari or Kuka Sikhs
    Sahajdhari Sikh
    Ravidasi
    [edit]Persian religions

    Main article: Persian religions
    Manichaeism
    Mazdakism
    Yazdânism
    Alevi
    Yarsani
    Yazidi
    Zoroastrianism
    Zurvanism
    [edit]East Asian religions

    Main article: East Asian religions
    [edit]Confucianism
    Main article: Confucianism
    Neo-Confucianism
    New Confucianism
    [edit]Shinto
    Main articles: Shinto and Shinto sects and schools
    [edit]Taoism
    Main article: Taoism
    [edit]Other
    Caodaism
    Chondogyo
    Chinese folk religion
    Falun Gong
    I-Kuan Tao
    Jeung San Do
    Legalism
    Mohism
    [edit]African diasporic religions

    African diasporic religions are a number of related religions that developed in the Americas among African slaves and their descendants in various countries of the Caribbean Islands and Latin America, as well as parts of the southern United States. They derive from African traditional religions, especially of West and Central Africa, showing similarities to the Yoruba religion in particular.
    See also: African diasporic religions
    Batuque
    Candomblé
    Dahomey mythology
    Haitian mythology
    Kumina
    Macumba
    Mami Wata
    Obeah
    Oyotunji
    Quimbanda
    Santería (Lukumi)
    Umbanda
    Vodou
    [edit]Indigenous traditional religions

    See also: Paganism and Folk religion
    Traditionally, these faiths have all been classified "Pagan", but scholars prefer the terms "indigenous/primal/folk/ethnic religions".
    [edit]African
    Main article: African traditional religions
    West Africa
    Akan mythology
    Ashanti mythology (Ghana)
    Dahomey (Fon) mythology
    Efik mythology (Nigeria, Cameroon)
    Igbo mythology (Nigeria, Cameroon)
    Isoko mythology (Nigeria)
    Yoruba mythology (Nigeria, Benin)
    Central Africa
    Bushongo mythology (Congo)
    Bambuti (Pygmy) mythology (Congo)
    Lugbara mythology (Congo)
    East Africa
    Akamba mythology (East Kenya)
    Dinka mythology (Sudan)
    Lotuko mythology (Sudan)
    Masai mythology (Kenya, Tanzania)
    Southern Africa
    Khoikhoi mythology
    Lozi mythology (Zambia)
    Tumbuka mythology (Malawi)
    Zulu mythology (South Africa)
    [edit]American
    Main article: Native American mythology
    Abenaki mythology
    Aztec mythology
    Blackfoot mythology
    Cherokee mythology
    Chickasaw mythology
    Choctaw mythology
    Creek mythology
    Crow mythology
    Ghost Dance
    Guarani mythology
    Haida mythology
    Ho-Chunk mythology
    Hopi mythology
    Huron mythology
    Inca mythology
    Inuit mythology
    Iroquois mythology
    Kwakiutl mythology
    Lakota mythology
    Leni Lenape mythology
    Longhouse religion
    Maya mythology
    Midewiwin
    Native American Church
    Navajo mythology
    Nootka mythology
    Olmec mythology
    Pawnee mythology
    Salish mythology
    Seneca mythology
    Selk'nam religion
    Tsimshian mythology
    Urarina
    Ute mythology
    Zuni mythology
    [edit]Eurasian
    Main article: Eurasian Indigenous Religions
    Asian
    Bön
    Chinese mythology
    Japanese mythology
    Koshinto
    Siberian Shamanism
    Tengriism
    European
    Estonian mythology
    Eskimo religion
    Finnish mythology and Finnish paganism
    Hungarian folk religion
    Sami religion (including the Noaidi)
    Tadibya
    [edit]Oceania/Pacific
    Australian Aboriginal mythology
    Austronesian beliefs
    Balinese mythology
    Javanese beliefs
    Melanesian mythology
    Micronesian mythology
    Modekngei
    Nauruan indigenous religion
    Philippine mythology
    Anito
    Gabâ
    Kulam
    Polynesian mythology
    Hawaiian mythology
    Maori mythology
    Maori religion
    Rapa Nui mythology
    Moai
    Tangata manu
    [edit]Cargo cults
    Main article: Cargo cults
    John Frum
    Johnson cult
    Prince Philip Movement
    Vailala Madness
    [edit]Historical polytheism

    Further information: Prehistoric religion and History of religion
    [edit]Ancient Near Eastern
    Main article: Ancient Near Eastern religions
    Ancient Egyptian religion
    Ancient Semitic religions
    Mesopotamian mythology
    Arabian mythology (pre-Islamic)
    Babylonian and Assyrian religion
    Babylonian mythology
    Chaldean mythology
    Canaanite mythology
    Canaanite religion
    Hittite mythology
    Persian mythology
    Sumerian mythology
    [edit]Indo-European
    Main article: Proto-Indo-European religion
    Proto-Indo-Iranian religion
    Zoroastrianism
    Historical Vedic religion
    Baltic polytheism
    Celtic polytheism
    Brythonic mythology
    Gaelic mythology
    Germanic polytheism
    Anglo-Saxon religion
    Norse religion
    Continental Germanic religion
    Greek polytheism
    Hungarian polytheism
    Finnish polytheism
    Roman polytheism
    Slavic polytheism
    [edit]Hellenistic
    Main article: Hellenistic religion
    Mystery religions
    Eleusinian Mysteries
    Mithraism
    Orphism
    Pythagoreanism
    Early Christianity
    Gallo-Roman religion
    [edit]Neopaganism

    Main article: List of Neopagan movements
    [edit]New Age, Esotericism, Mysticism

    Main articles: New Age, Esotericism, and Mysticism
    Anthroposophy
    Christian mysticism
    Esoteric Christianity
    Hindu mysticism
    Martinism
    Meher Baba
    **** mysticism
    Occultism
    Rosicrucian
    Ancient Mystical Order Rosae Crucis
    Ancient Order of the Rosicrucians
    Rosicrucian Fellowship
    Surat Shabd Yoga
    Tantra
    Ananda Marga Tantra-Yoga
    Sufism
    Thelema
    [edit]Left-Hand Path
    Main article: Left-Hand Path and Right-Hand Path
    Luciferianism
    Satanism
    Setianism
    [edit]Magic
    Main article: Magic (religion)
    Hoodoo (Rootwork)
    New Orleans Voodoo
    Kulam - Filipino witchcraft
    Magick
    Chaos magic
    Enochian magic
    Demonolatry
    Goetia
    Pow-wow
    Seid (shamanic magic)
    Vaastu Shastra
    Witchcraft
    [edit]New religious movements

    Main article: List of new religious movements
    [edit]Shinshukyo
    Main article: Shinshūkyō
    Church of World Messianity
    PL Kyodan
    Seicho-No-Ie
    [edit]Fictional religions

    Main article: List of fictional religions
    [edit]Parody or mock religions

    Church of Euthanasia
    Church of the SubGenius
    The Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster
    Invisible Pink Unicorn
    Kibology
    Landover Baptist Church
    [edit]Others

    Unitarian Universalism
    Discordianism
    Ethical Culture
    Fellowship of Reason
    Humanism
    Secular Humanism
    Juche
    Subud

    Your final points are moot. If you even know what a Christian is, we're certainly not discussing hypocrites, therefore Christians do much more good than harm. Believe me.
     
  2. shiruken

    shiruken Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    156
    Likes Received:
    0
    Oh really? I believe the Crusades and Inquisition alone raise an objection to that claim. Throw in the priest child abuse scandals, the Church's attempts to disrupt the advancement of science, the witch trials, and the denying of equal rights to individuals based on their beliefs, sexual orientation, etc. and I'd say there's quite a lot of harm the christian religion has done.
     
  3. aMoeba

    aMoeba Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,369
    Likes Received:
    0
    Your purely overbiased atheist overtone sickens me.

    What has true Christianity done? No harm. It has brought peace to millions upon millions (much more than any deaths caused by any false religious practices).

    Said better than I would:

    Care for the helpless, Christians were really the first, to on a large scale, start the care for orphans and widows and set up the system needed to ensure this would happen. This continues to this day around the world.

    Also, it was religious authorities who claimed that all people, not just those from the Old World, were to be treated as people. This was mostly in response to the treatment of the Native Americans of Central and South America following the European Conquest. It was the religious orders that taught these men how to take care of themselves and educated them as well as protected them from becoming slaves on a plantation.

    Christians made up the bulk of the abolitionist movements and fought to have all the slaves freed throughout the world.

    It was the Christian monks who preserved the knowledge of the ancient world, copying and preserving texts for later generations to use, by hand until the invention of the printing press.

    With the Reformation came the drive to educate the masses so that they could read God's word and understand it for themselves and established the idea of a public education system.

    The foundations of modern science was pioneered by Christians who saw the natural laws as being set up by God, knowable and testable. It is from these men and women searching to find how God caused things to work that the scientific revolution started.

    Christians started the idea of nursing and established the International Red Cross.

    (albeit repetitive a tad bit):

    Christian churches and other organizations, like the Salvation Army, have set up hospitals and clinics, schools, colleges, libraries, soup kitchens, food drives, flop houses, orphanages, and elderly services and homes. We set up farms in third world countries and crusade for the rights of oppressed people in all nations to live free of fear or torture from their own government. We fund and man relief efforts in times of natural disaster, like Katrina. All of this beside the simple act of teaching the truth of God to the world.

    Not only those, but Christianity helps millions of people, people who don't even believe in what they do.

    An interesting .pdf: http://www.findingmoreatprinceton.com/files/10_HarmGood.pdf

    When one interrogates the assumption that Christianity has done more harm than good to humankind, we see that it is an idea founded in a rather shoddily conjured historicism. Sure, Christianity has been used to justify a lot of evil—but so have atheism, and paganism, and virtually all other –isms the world has ever seen. Any organized belief system, after all, can be skewed to fit the most heinous inclinations of a wayward soul. In fact, it is often the most secular, areligious societies that wreak the most havoc, not the Christian ones. Think about Stalinist Russia or the various other communist regimes that dotted the globe in the twentieth century. They rejected any belief in God and systematically slaughtered millions of their own people. Think about the French Revolution—a thoroughly secular, godless movement that resulted in the barbaric purging of wide swaths of the innocent citizenry. Clearly a belief in God is not a prerequisite for horrific violence. And then there is the much larger human history (10,000+ years) predating Christ’s arrival on earth: and surprise surprise, all of it is littered with bloodshed and brutality.

    Far from a malevolent force of destruction in the world, however, Christianity has done more to make the world a better place than any other organized movement or guiding principle in history. Almost every major reform movement or social-justice campaign can be traced back to Christians, or at least Christian teachings. Christians led the way in the abolition of slavery and were the first to publicly deem it immoral and denounce it as sin (Wesley, Wilberforce, etc). Christians have historically been the first and most active responders to international relief, hunger, and justice issues, and most major charities and humanitarian organizations (Red Cross, Salvation Army, Habitat for Humanity, Samaritan’s Purse, Feed the Children, World Vision, etc) have decidedly Christian roots. Christians were the first to establish hospitals, schools, and universities (such as Oxford, Cambridge, Harvard, and Yale). They led the way in literacy movements, adult education, prison reform, substance-abuse programs, and many other progressive reforms.

    C+V of my own thoughts.
     
  4. Norlinsky

    Norlinsky Guest

    Where do dinosaurs fit into Christianity?
     
  5. Eyeless Sid

    Eyeless Sid Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,254
    Likes Received:
    1
    I choose all of them because they all have a belief in a higher power even the extreemist/violent ones, but yes Christianity has contributed to world violence even Hitler was christian which we already proved . He may be not an ideal cchristian but one none the less. Also yes There have been many movements to better the world done by various religions including Christianity but there have been curruption in them just as much. Nemi gave us a good example a few pages back where Pastor I believe had used donation money assumingly to buy himself a nice appartment well in the millions at the exspense of where the money should have gone . Money skimming is not the only curruption how about priests that sexualy assualted the choir boys or how religious fanitics kill in the name of God. Theres lots of nasty things in the world I seem to be able to connect one religion or anouther to many conflics or indifferences we see every day.Like it or not religion has cause harm even if its intentions are good. Global warming excluded thats all our damn faults lol. ;]
     
    #2145 Eyeless Sid, Jul 20, 2009
    Last edited: Jul 20, 2009
  6. aMoeba

    aMoeba Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,369
    Likes Received:
    0
    No they don't.

    If Hitler was not an ideal Christian, there's absolutely no reason for him to represent all of us.

    Why should hypocrites represent Christianity? Its like getting the fattest man alive to be an athlete in the Olympics commercial. Sure, he can call himself an athlete, and he can try to be one, but why should he represent? He doesn't.
     
  7. Eyeless Sid

    Eyeless Sid Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,254
    Likes Received:
    1
    Hitler deffinatly doesn't represent Christianity I was just saying that corruption happens to every thing and makes it rotten he happened to be in association with Christianity .He met with the Pope and openly belived in God he eventualy cracked and became a dictator but he had belief still. As bad as a human he was he was a beliver a bad one though. Jesus is the representation of Christainity but when you have extreemists that follow by his word but misunderstand them as Hitler did then its makes the whole religion dull. Your only as strong as your weakest link Hitler is that weak link.
    My point: curruption sucks and its hurting rather than helping.
     
  8. aMoeba

    aMoeba Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,369
    Likes Received:
    0
    Uh, no.

    Religion has no relation to being as strong as its weakest link.

    Religion is represented by the purest form. Christianity, a religion, is represented by Jesus, its purest form. Not the other way around. You're essentially saying that a religion only lives up to its worst.... which is ridiculous. I can profess to be God's chosen one and go out tonight and kill hundreds of people, set houses on fire, rob banks, whatever. You can blame Christianity, but that's not the cause at all.

    Again, its like how Jack Thompson talks about video games. He blames all these issues people have on video games. Everyone who plays video games knows that its not true at all, its just that Jack Thompson is trying to find a reason for it, and that anything can be perverted to one's favor.

    Now, let Jack Thompson represent atheism, video games on Christianity, and plays with follows.
     
  9. Eyeless Sid

    Eyeless Sid Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,254
    Likes Received:
    1
    Nothing is pure and most things such as groups are always judged by its strongest parts and its weakest. Christianity Is a very large group thus making it vunerable to having some bad but still having good . Most people only see the bad because thats all we see on the news nut at the same time as a society thats all we care about . lol we as humans suck / So I stand by the part about Stong and weak links thats all that matters to us yes the Red cross fed and clothed thousands of children today but at the same time some where ing the middle of some 3rd world country a massacre killing thousands is happening , there could be a variety of reasons why this happens. Money land and Religion are the primary causes for conflicsts and wars . We cant live with out money as a society and we need land to live on and even if we have both if anouther person has a different belief we just might take there money and land . Now this is a weird part i think anyways if there was a common belief then there would be less conflics but we as humans are stuburn. Now to finish this rant I started ,well If there was no reason to fight or at least less reasons to fight than the world would be more peaceful. The problem is that we have made religions to at the begining bring people together but now as time has moved on it has divided us. Im not saying stop helping people or stop having morals I just want people to stop fighting over their beliefs because its doing harm . I state it again We humans are stuburn and we hate change as a species.

    Sorry if I rambled off lol im alittle tired being as its 2 in the morning haha.
     
  10. aMoeba

    aMoeba Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,369
    Likes Received:
    0
    Jesus was a pure example.

    Jack Thompson is on the news too.

    Bullcrap. Give me some proof of everyday third world country religion war.
     
  11. CHUCK

    CHUCK Why so serious?
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    4,406
    Likes Received:
    31
    If god created everything, then technically isn't every bad thing that's happened ever gods doing? Think about it. EVERY bad thing that's happened in history went without any intervention from a so called "God"

    God is merely there as an emphasis on just the good things that happen, when the bad outweighs it. It's all a part of the illusion.
     
  12. Nemihara

    Nemihara Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    5,071
    Likes Received:
    1
    Technically speaking my parents are still Christian. And my sister is athiest of her own accord.
     
  13. xxAl Capwnagexx

    xxAl Capwnagexx Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,579
    Likes Received:
    3
    I'll intervene on aMoeba and Sid's argument. I promise it won't take me long.

    You can't blame religion for violence. Blame HUMAN NATURE. Religion is merely used as a vehicle for violence that would have happened anyway. Many might object, but without the modern, open minded upbringing that all of us here have had the pleasure of, it is HUMAN NATURE in it's most primitive form to kill and fight. Humans are violent creatures like any other animal, except more so (see Weapons, Nuclear).

    Before you bring religion on me...I'm an atheist. Just intervening on an argument. :]
     
  14. RadiantRain

    RadiantRain Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,346
    Likes Received:
    0
    He created our foundation, not tanks or guns. We did that...

    Then never mind what I said...
     
  15. shiruken

    shiruken Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    156
    Likes Received:
    0
    You can blame religion for violence when the people who commit the acts explicitly say they're doing it for religious reasons. The word "jihad" literally means a holy war against an immoral infidel. The terrorists, while they are interpreting the Qur'an in an overtly violent manner, believe they are doing the work of Allah. They believe they are cleansing the world of immorality, much like the Christians sought to do with the Crusades in the Holy Land.

    Violence may be human nature, but organized violence is not.


    Our scientific and technological advances over millenia.
     
    #2155 shiruken, Jul 20, 2009
    Last edited: Jul 20, 2009
  16. makisupa007

    makisupa007 Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    946
    Likes Received:
    2
    We've already argued this. Christians deciding to come out against slavery is a good thing I guess, except that their handbook for moral action, the bible, condones slavery and even instructs on the proper way and duration to beat your slave.

    Christians have the exact same propensity for positive moral actions as any human does. Standing up and condemning slavery is the right thing for a Christian to do, as long as they understand that doing that goes against their holy instruction book.
     
  17. aMoeba

    aMoeba Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,369
    Likes Received:
    0
    Slavery in the Bible was drastically different than what slavery is commonly and modernly defined by now. In Bible times, if you were poor and could not hold your own, you could offer yourself as a slave and your slave owner would take care of you/let you live [with him] while you did his chores and whatnot.

    I've never in my lifetime seen a verse that says how to beat your slave and the duration of the beatings... please source this.
     
  18. makisupa007

    makisupa007 Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    946
    Likes Received:
    2
    Slaves

    Here:

    When a man strikes his male or female slave with a rod so hard that the slave dies under his hand, he shall be punished. If, however, the slave survives for a day or two, he is not to be punished, since the slave is his own property. (Exodus 21:20-21 NAB)


    And here's some more regarding slavery and sexual slavery of young girls:

    However, you may purchase male or female slaves from among the foreigners who live among you. You may also purchase the children of such resident foreigners, including those who have been born in your land. You may treat them as your property, passing them on to your children as a permanent inheritance. You may treat your slaves like this, but the people of Israel, your relatives, must never be treated this way. (Leviticus 25:44-46 NLT)

    If you buy a Hebrew slave, he is to serve for only six years. Set him free in the seventh year, and he will owe you nothing for his freedom. If he was single when he became your slave and then married afterward, only he will go free in the seventh year. But if he was married before he became a slave, then his wife will be freed with him. If his master gave him a wife while he was a slave, and they had sons or daughters, then the man will be free in the seventh year, but his wife and children will still belong to his master. But the slave may plainly declare, 'I love my master, my wife, and my children. I would rather not go free.' If he does this, his master must present him before God. Then his master must take him to the door and publicly pierce his ear with an awl. After that, the slave will belong to his master forever. (Exodus 21:2-6 NLT)

    When a man sells his daughter as a slave, she will not be freed at the end of six years as the men are. If she does not please the man who bought her, he may allow her to be bought back again. But he is not allowed to sell her to foreigners, since he is the one who broke the contract with her. And if the slave girl's owner arranges for her to marry his son, he may no longer treat her as a slave girl, but he must treat her as his daughter. If he himself marries her and then takes another wife, he may not reduce her food or clothing or fail to sleep with her as his wife. If he fails in any of these three ways, she may leave as a free woman without making any payment. (Exodus 21:7-11 NLT)

    I wanted to comment on this one in particular. It is clearly saying that if a man buys a girl as a slave and then marries her, he is allowed to marry another girl and keep his young wife slave, as long as he continues to feed, clothe, and screw her.

    Slaves, obey your earthly masters with deep respect and fear. Serve them sincerely as you would serve Christ. (Ephesians 6:5 NLT)

    However you want to define slavery, how could god condone any of this awful behavior? Answer - The bible was written by humans that wanted and needed to perpetuate these practices that were common in this time. They wrote these passages with no consualtation from a higher power, but did so to control a population.

    It is possible that some type of God exists, but if a Christian God exists then I am truly embarrassed to be the creation of a being condoning any of this. In my experience most Christians have stronger morals than their own God. There is nothing wrong with adopting a strong moral belief system, but the foundation that Christians stand on is archaic at best.
     
    #2158 makisupa007, Jul 20, 2009
    Last edited: Jul 20, 2009
  19. aMoeba

    aMoeba Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,369
    Likes Received:
    0
    You are right that humans wanted these practices. God doesn't exactly condone it, he works within it.

    Even though slavery is taught in the Bible as violently as it is (how you stated) doesn't mean God condones it. God only makes rules inside of what we ourselves have already made. We invented slavery, not God. I mean, you look at both definitions of slavery, and of course offering yourself up to be taken care of is sensible and certainly justifiable. While however that only existed in the New Testament era, which is why the reference of Ephesians is literal to the sense that if you do offer yourself up you should obey your master.

    God doesn't condone sin, but as you can see, its allowed. God made rules and allowances inside of the ones we built for ourselves. If you read Matthew 19:8, Jesus allowed people to divorce because of the hardness of their hearts. Now was it condoned? No. Allowed? Yes. In the verses you listed (except for Ephesians I'd think) God made rules in what was already made. There's plenty of Bible heroes who God used that had sinned more than many of us (see: Moses, Samson, David), yet they used them for great things in His will. God permits their freedom, but uses the system and the people according to what their will is.

    If that wasn't relevant to slavery in your eyes, basically, God saw man's fallen system of slavery, and he made rules inside of it. I'm pretty sure he knew that they probably wouldn't be completely convinced to turn their morals in the opposite direction in the first place.
     
  20. makisupa007

    makisupa007 Ancient
    Senior Member

    Messages:
    946
    Likes Received:
    2
    You are really having to stretch your logic here in order to accommodate your beliefs.

    Here are some verses that should be included in the bible under your logic of God allowing sin, just not condoning it and trying to give the sin a silver lining.


    Let there be pause after five days of heroin binging. The sixth day belongs to God and should be dedicated to sobriety. When sharing in the joys of heroin with your children they must rest and become sober for a period after only 3 days. (Bullshiticus 21:7-11 NLT)


    When raping a family friend, you shall be severely punished if the victim is not treated with divine care. Thou shalt make sure a pillow is positioned correctly under the victim's head. The hand restraints must also be loose enough not to burn the skin of the victim, but not so loose that the victim may escape. (Nonsensicus 21:2-6 NLT)


    By allowing those verses to be included in the bible, God has done no good towards reducing the sin of slavery. In fact, by including those versus, God has immensely perpetuated those practices allowing Christians to look to their good book in order to justify the beating and keeping of slaves. I mean, God says it's OK so......People still use these outdated bible inclusions to justify their hatred of and believed moral superiority over homosexuals. If slavery is wrong, if it is a sin, if it is clearly a horrible practice and a dark time in humanity, why wouldn't God just say it's wrong and tell us to cut it the **** out? Why would he say to beat your slaves to within inches of their lives, but not quite kill them? What kind of God are you arguing for?
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page