They're all just a render slapped to a distracting and messy background. Sorry, but I'm not voting. Keep trying though, and eventually you'll be making really good sigs.
Are you asking for a lock because you got harsh criticism? Seriously? Like, no offense, but harsh criticism is the only thing that will ever help you improve. I got/still can get some harsh CnC from people. It's the only reason I ever got good, or at least, better than I was when I began... Don't just ask for a lock because you can't handle the criticism.
no I'm not, I'm locking it because the sigs are horrible, I've been browsing and using some new techniques, and realize how bad these sigs were, all I did was make a back ground and slap some renders on. They had good criticism, and I looked for some tutorials and have learned some new ****, I also scrapped the sig.
Most of the time harsh criticism is from amateurs who don't know how to make signatures, and think that they can give good criticism. I won't name these people, but they piss me off. One in particular is ****ing high on his chair I would love go and kill him myself. And biasm. Most people rate my signatures low because of the render I chose. You know who you are. So really, don't take it too hard. Besides, your current signature isn't bad.
my current is ok but I had an older sig where I slapped renders on, and it didn't look good, low quality the **** was horrible, I just learned some new stuff, before when I made the sig on this thread I didn't even know how to flatten an image. lal yea fail, here's something I learned.