Sorry, but

Agreed. 100%.

 

Agreed. 100%.

Now i'm like:
True, i don't like them very much. I mean, if its just some random graphic, then it's okay, but a popout sig looks dumb 90 percent of the time.

ALSO, those sigs that are just text with a clipping mask, GER!

 

qft

qft

 

asdfsadf

 

I think about 90% are bad, but some popouts are good. Very rare though.

 

I think they all suck, except this one strikes me for some reason: http://img210.imageshack.us/img210/756/popoutsig2iw.png

 

If it was a little less blurry, I agree. It goes with the background nicely.

 

Disagreed. 100%

No, I'm serious, I respectfully disagree with your opinions.

 

OY!!!! haha its the only thing im good at! or was.. i havent tried making sigs... and thanks sw33ny.. who likes my pop-out? i like them sometimes, but not often. i actually prefer my gears one, but kept this one cause people liked it more

 

Just because you view something over-used, doesn't make it bad. It all depends what you are trying to go for here.

As for your sig knight, I <3 because it is Republic Commando. Making that sig taller, and not pop out would totally ruin it.

 

In some situations they work brilliantly but when they're done "just because" they generally don't turn out all that well.

 

I agree that they do make a sig automatically good but some KK's popouts have been decent

 

Popout signatures can be brilliant if they're done correctly.

 

I don't think it makes it automatically ugly.

Somtimes it works out very nicely, if its done well.

 

Don't flame me for this but...

They are usually ugly because noobs make them. They think something that extravagant will suffice for their shitty skills. sorry

 

I just gave it a go and i thought it came out okay...

I know, i guess you can call me a hypocrite. : (

 

this was my first attempt to get back at sig making. i made it for a CGN race night