That's a shame. It has some fun combat. Prey was my personal favorite from last year. Has an awesome world and the whole game is about problem solving Edit: quit changing your posts after you post haha
I'll admit, a lot if Doom felt like it didn't matter what weapon you were using you simply had to put it damage snd avoid projectiles, but I still found it fun. I think there's a lot to improve though
To be honest, I barely even looked at the maps due to MCC being itself and issues with loading files.
Chasm could have had spawn issues, not to mention it's probably one of those layouts that is going to get a love hate reaction. Of course I'm biased and think Chasm is awesome because I worked on it. I know lifts and teleporters are too confusing for players in 2018 and it pisses me off a lot, but that's a whole other matter. Your Chillout remake is fun but I don't think a remake should ever win a contest like this if the intention is to provide new content. MCC is one giant remake as is. I'm sure I'd have more fun on Chillout than most of these maps but it isn't entirely your design, and if I were a judge I just wouldn't think it right to put a remake in the finalists if money were on the line. It'd still probably work well for matchmaking but I imagine there was a priority on original designs (although I still see too much Midship so it doesn't matter anyway)!
One of those doors closed into itself too much and the other didn't even fully close. That still annoys me to this day.