So much smexy. Really like it man, nice work. the D-pad looks a little distorted but besides that it's done well. Did you use a stencil for the letters??
This looks pretty awesome., the shading and general shape are both very well done. The values on the four buttons could be better to make them appear more three dimmensional and I think the lower lines on the thumbsticks are a little too dark. Additionally, the bottom right looks a little weird. Good stuff man.
Yeah, the dpad was rushed a bit, I redid it about 6 times, so I tried not to worry about it that much. No, couldn't find a stencil with that font, had to copy it :s Really? I thought the bottom left looked worse than the bottom right IMO, and yeah, the four buttons do look kind of flat, tried to add some kind of shadow below them to fix that
The x looks 3D, maybe if you made them more round like that one (notice how the others are more oval-y)