It seems like the party leader would have a hard time getting everyone to understand all of the rules and enforcing them. I have an idea for that: make the gametype juggernaut and allow god to see waypoints of everyone at all times.
It's not that hard, especially as we KNOW who the killer is. So if halfway through the game it say someone kills someone and the person who killed them was not the killer, then there's a good chance of shenanigains going on. Also as said earlier in the thread Juggernaut was tried but, I believe, there was no real way for the flames to be removed. There was someway that it did not work anyway. I also don't think there's a way to make only one person able to see the waypoints.
Just downloaded Equilibrium: Clue and while it's incredibly disorienting at first, it's by far the most interesting and surreal map I've ever come across. Give it a go. That's because they were testing it with the killer as the Juggernaut, meaning the flames were a dead give away as to who the killer was. If God was made the Juggernaut, then the flames would actually be very befitting.
Problem is that it gets a little difficult in the large games this is targeted at. Most people in large parties are too busy shouting crap about the maps they hate or want played to actually listen to the rules. As any teacher will tell you, even if the concept is simple there will always be atleast 1 out of the 15 that just don't get it or aren't trying to.
Even if it played better as a Juggernaut game type, I think the skull is a very important ritualistic component in the game of Clue, I never played it back in Halo 3, but the logo has a huge skull on it, so I don't think the Oddball's going anywhere.
I suppose although I've rarely, if ever, experienced this problem. I know. However, an idea is an idea.
You should release the slayer version of this, less honor rules and god can play too The way I've been playing it is so that nobody picks up the oddball because it isn't necessary anymore. Anyways, I absolutely love Reach clue, I'm thinking of making a map for it.
Sounds good, but finding people to play with (who will keep to the honour rules) would be hard. There's no organised events is there? I'd love to try this out...